Apps scale; calls convert. That is the honest tradeoff every broker faces when a new investor signs up, and it shapes what your first week as an investor looks like. Onboarding apps are available at midnight, cost nothing, and work if you are self-directed. They fail when you stall at step three of seven and nobody notices. Onboarding calls put a human on the line who walks you through account type, first funding, and first investment in about 20 minutes. They work because appointments create commitment. They also cost the provider money, so expect a product pitch attached.

Layered on top of both paths is the promotion, the cash bonus or pricing offer designed to get you through the door. Promotions feel universal because the advertising is loud. The recorded data tells a quieter story.

Online broker promotions, counted

Bar chart of promotion offers recorded across 50 US brokerages: 44 record no promotion, 4 state a cash bonus between $25 and $200, and 2 record a pricing discount offer with no cash bonus stated
Source: BrokerCompare database, 50 US brokerages, Sep 15 2026 snapshot; brokers counted by the promotion recorded for each.

Only 6 of the 50 brokerages in our dataset record a promotion at all. Four state a cash bonus: Ally Invest records up to $200 with a $1,000 minimum deposit, Betterment records $100 with a $2,500 minimum deposit, Greenlight records $50, and Stash records $25 for a $5 investment. The other two are pricing offers rather than cash: TradeStation records a limited-time $0 options fee offer tied to a $5,000 minimum deposit, and Lightspeed Trading records 40% off commissions with a $10,000 minimum deposit. The other 44 brokerages record no promotion in the snapshot.

Read those numbers the way an onboarding team would. The stated cash runs from $25 to $200, and the serious money asks for a serious deposit first. A $200 bonus on a $1,000 deposit is a genuine 20% nudge. A bonus that requires $10,000 to unlock a discount is a filter for customers the broker already wanted. Either way, the promotion is doing onboarding work: it gives you a deadline, a first deposit, and a reason to finish step seven instead of stalling at step three.

Read a promotion by its conditions, not its headline

Online Broker Promotions and Onboarding: Apps vs Calls, What Actually Gets You Started
Image via Wikimedia Commons

The dataset records three conditions next to each offer, and the conditions are where the onboarding actually happens. The minimum deposit is the first: the recorded offers ask for as little as $5 (Stash) and as much as $10,000 (Lightspeed), with Ally at $1,000, Betterment at $2,500 and TradeStation at $5,000 between them. The expiry date is the second: three of the six record one, Ally at the end of 2026, Betterment on October 22, 2026, and TradeStation on September 30, 2026, all as recorded in the September 15 snapshot. The third condition is the form of the reward. Cash lands in the account and stays; a pricing discount only pays if you trade enough to use it, which means the broker earns the promotion back from your activity. A beginner reading an offer should ask, in order: what deposit unlocks it, when does it expire, and does it pay me for starting or pay me for trading? The first kind of promotion helps onboarding. The second kind is onboarding for the broker.

What actually gets you started

What actually gets beginners started is not information, and it is not a bonus either. It is a funded account with an automated monthly investment. Everything else is preparation for that moment. The call should end with three things done: account open, first deposit scheduled, and first investment automated. The app should be judged by the same standard. If the flow ends with a watchlist and a congratulations screen, it has onboarded you into an audience, not into investing.

Before a promotion moves you, price the exit

A promotion is a reason to open an account, not a reason to move one. If you already invest somewhere, the bonus has to beat the cost of switching: transfer fees, closeout charges, and the hassle of moving tax lots. Run the numbers in the SwitchCost Checker, which prices a switch from the same recorded fee data, before a deadline talks you into it. And read the promotion terms the way the dataset records them, with the minimum deposit and the expiry date attached. A bonus with a $10,000 door is not a beginner offer, whatever the advertisement says. This is education, not financial advice: chase the funded, automated account, and let the promotion be the tiebreaker, never the reason.

Sources: FINRA, SEC